Amhurst Asylum Rating (average): (1) Amhurst Asylum Attraction Type: Haunted Attractions 228 s 500 west valparaiso Indiana 46385 Amhurst Asylum is the number one ranked haunt from 2013! Come see our 5th year of expansion with 35 fully themed environments. Once you step inside you will be at the mercy of the twisted Staff and their demented Patients they watch over! Website: http://www.amhurstasylum.com Phone Number: (888) 813-4571 Email: email@example.com Ratings There are no reviews yet. Rated # 1 last year and this year they have adde 9 more rooms and extended your stay. A must see attraction by far. Bob Schappert | 10/11/2014 Please login to rate this listing. Directions to listing From: Current location Specific Address Travel Mode: Driving Public Transit Walking Cycling Annabelle Not very scary at all. They do touch you, which is weird…but not scary. Definitely not worth the $25.